The willy-nilly approach of most investors gives them a lack of solid foundation from which to make decisions. As a result, investor allocations and stock picks are frequently not aligned with their goals. One consequence is that the typical investor spends time moving money from one investment to another, trying to meet an obscure goal. Investing without a plan, or road map, leads to a lack of discipline. The lack of discipline allows your psychological biases and emotions to invade the process.
Ultimately, these problems cause many people to be poor investors. Indeed, investors who must make their own decisions underperform the market indexes. Consider the performance of 66,465 households that owned stock through a discount broker from 1991 to 1996. The average household in this sample owned just 4.3 stocks worth a total of $47,334. The first problem we can identify is that investors do not adequately diversify. Owning only four stocks? Having such a concentrated portfolio is very risky, "Foolish Risks."
What was the performance of these investors? First, the investors tended to pick riskier stocks. Specifically, they preferred the stocks of smaller companies. On average, the higher risk was rewarded with an average gross annual return of 18.7% compared to the market index of 17.9%. However, the average investor also turned over 75% of his or her stocks per year. That is, the average portfolio experienced the sale of three-quarters of its stocks to fund the purchase of other stocks. Due to the cost of trading, the net annual performance of the investors was only 16.4%. Individual investors underperformed the market by 1.5% per year. The more active the investor, the worse the net return. For example, the 20% of the investors that did the most trading underperformed the market by 4.8%. This compares to a return that beat the market by 0.6% per year for the 20% of investors that did the least amount of trading. Some of the underperformance of the active traders is due to transaction costs and some is caused by making bad choices. Active trading magnifies your emotions and psychological biases that cause these bad choices.
Also, the investors with the largest stock portfolios performed poorly. The 20% of investors owning the portfolios with the largest stock value had, on average, $149,710 in stocks. These investors underperformed the market by 1.7% per year. Who are these investors with the larger portfolios and the more active trading? It seems that a larger portfolio and a higher degree of trading would be associated with more experienced investors. If true, this is a frightening thought. That is, people may actually get worse as investors as they gain more experience. This phenomenon can be caused by the psychological biases, like overconfidence, "Behavioral Finance."
Of course, this study examined the average investor portfolio. Some investors experience something much worse than poor returns. Some investors, like Irv and Louise Trockman, experience an investment blunder that sets their wealth back many years.
Thanks Darren Winters Of Win Investing
Thursday, 28 June 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment